Choosing the right lawn tractor can be daunting. This review compares two popular Craftsman models—the 5500 and the 917.20403—to help you select the best fit for your needs and yard size. We'll examine engine power, cutting deck size, maneuverability, and overall cost-effectiveness. For more information on similar Craftsman models, check out this helpful resource: Craftsman 5100 Review.
Craftsman 5500 vs. Craftsman 917.20403: A Detailed Comparison
Both tractors offer reliable performance, but their strengths cater to different yard sizes and user preferences. The key differences lie in engine power, cutting deck size, and resulting maneuverability.
Engine Power and Performance
The Craftsman 917.20403 boasts a more powerful 24 horsepower, 724cc Briggs & Stratton engine, making it ideal for large lawns and challenging terrain. This is akin to choosing a heavy-duty truck for hauling versus a compact car for city driving. The Craftsman 5500, conversely, features a smaller displacement engine (exact specifications not provided in the source material), offering easier handling and maneuverability. This makes it perfect for smaller to medium-sized yards with obstacles. Which engine is "better" depends entirely on your yard's size and complexity. Do you need the raw power of the 917.20403, or is the easier handling of the 5500 more important?
Cutting Deck Size and Maneuverability
The 917.20403 features a wider 54-inch cutting deck, significantly reducing mowing time on large, open areas. This is excellent for efficiency on expansive lawns. The Craftsman 5500, however, has a 48-inch deck. While this means slightly more passes are needed for larger yards, it leads to superior maneuverability in smaller, more complex landscapes. The smaller size makes navigating around obstacles like trees and flowerbeds much easier.
Key Feature Comparison
| Feature | Craftsman 5500 Lawn Tractor | Craftsman 917.20403 |
|---|---|---|
| Engine Size | Smaller Displacement, likely lower horsepower | 24hp, 724cc |
| Cutting Deck Size | 48" | 54" |
| Maneuverability | Excellent, great for tight spaces | Less maneuverable, better for open areas |
| Ideal Yard Size | Smaller to medium-sized yards | Larger yards, open spaces |
| Typical Price | Generally more affordable | Expect a higher price tag |
Choosing the Right Tractor: A Step-by-Step Guide
Selecting the appropriate tractor hinges on your individual needs. Follow these steps to make an informed decision:
Assess Yard Size: Measure your lawn's dimensions and consider its complexity. Large, open areas benefit from the 917.20403's wider cutting deck, while intricate layouts are best suited to the 5500's maneuverability.
Identify Obstacles: Count trees, flowerbeds, and other obstacles. The more obstacles, the more valuable the 5500's agility becomes.
Set Your Budget: Consider the initial purchase price and potential future maintenance costs. The 5500 typically offers a lower initial investment.
Consider Your Experience Level: The 5500's smaller engine may be easier to handle and maintain for novice users.
Beyond the Specifications: Practical Considerations
While raw power is appealing, the 5500’s simpler design may mean lower maintenance costs and easier operation over the long term. The overall cost of ownership – factoring in fuel, repairs, and maintenance – is crucial. "The best" tractor isn't a single solution, but the one best tailored to your specific requirements. Carefully weigh your yard's characteristics, your budget, and maintenance considerations to make the best choice.